Top Menu

I Plead No Contest

There’s been much grumbling throughout the culture blogging community following Spring for Music’s announcement that they planned to launch a blogging competition to determine what they defined as the “Best Arts Blogger in America.” Granted, is seems as though they’ve toned down the PR speak a bit and are now calling it the “2012 Great Arts Blogger Challenge.”

But the real head scratcher in all of this is the American Idol style process, where the festival selects the topic for each round, means it isn’t really a blogging contest at all. It’s an old school essay contest.

Perhaps it is that sort of fast and loose approach that got under the skin of so many culture bloggers.

The arguable epicenter of ruffled feathers has been Iron Tongue of Midnight, where author Lisa Hirsch started off a volley of posts when she published a personal response to the fine folks at Spring for Music explaining why she didn’t plan to participate.

She followed up that contribution with a series of additional posts along with a compendium of disgruntlement which has been cataloging less than enthusiastic reactions throughout the culture webs.

Not long after that, one of the contest judges, Arts Journal founder Doug Mc Lennan, posted a general response to the blowback which one of my colleagues (and an institutional culture blogger) summed up by saying “it seems to have more thought than they put into the actual contest.”

If nothing else, all of this will hopefully demonstrate that although there’s not much rhyme, reason, or organization to what might be defined as the culture blogging community, it doesn’t have much trouble raising its collective hackles against top-down attempts to determine its value.

Just like most other culture bloggers, the folks at Spring for Music sent an open invitation my way, which I politely declined. I simply don’t have much interest in an essay contest billed as a blogging competition.

And since the initial topic doesn’t hold any interest for me, I don’t have plans to read any of the initial contributions. Consequently, if the subsequent topics are cut from the same cloth, I’ll likely continue in blissful ignorance.

But I am reading the posts that take issue with the contest. They all do a fine job at articulating one or more of my additional concerns but perhaps more importantly, they do a fine job at defining what makes a culture blog truly valuable:

5 Responses to I Plead No Contest

  1. Lisa Hirsch March 27, 2012 at 1:01 pm #

    Thanks for the shout-out! I updated my Reactions Around the Blogosphere post accordingly. :)

  2. Lisa Hirsch March 27, 2012 at 3:34 pm #

    The Arts Blogger Challenge page still says “Help us find (North) America’s Best Arts Blogger.”

    • Drew McManus March 27, 2012 at 3:36 pm #

      Ugh. I didn’t go looking around very much so I must have missed that one. I hope they have plans to edit all of those instances. Since I believe they are using a WordPress platform, there are plenty of handy search & Replace plugins that can make that otherwise arduous task a piece of cake.

  3. CK Dexter Haven March 29, 2012 at 7:22 pm #

    Many thanks for the mention, Mr. McManus.

    I wonder if there will be any further comment from Spring for Music on the whole concept, besides what Doug Mc Lennan already posted. Of course, if there were, I’m guessing Lisa would’ve mentioned it already in her “Compendium of disgruntlement” (which is an awesome description for it).

    Regardless, as I said, I barely have time to follow the things I really care about — like the 30 Piano art installation “Play Me, I’m Yours” being sponsored by LA Chamber Orchestra, the Dodgers getting decent ownership again, and USC Spring Football. Plus I’ve got a review I’ve got to write for the blog and I’m behind on some research for another post.

    Better get back to it. The life of an “arts blogger” is ever busy . . .

    Again, thanks!

    CKDH

    • Drew McManus March 31, 2012 at 3:56 pm #

      My apologies for the delayed reply but I agree, and there’s another interesting contribution from Linda Essign on this as well at http://creativeinfrastructure.org/2012/03/31/withdrawn/

      I love that “Play me, I’m yours” slogan. Terrific stuff and kudos to LACO for doing such great work with new music initiatives.

Leave a Reply