Top Menu

Imaginary Fiscal Distress Syndrome

Back in January of 2012 I published a post titled Do Some Orchestras Exaggerate Their Financial Position For Negotiation Leverage? Like most topical subjects, there was examination elsewhere throughout the culture blogging community with some in the Chicken Little circles suggesting such a notion was ludicrous. Consequently, I found Thomas Cott’s 8/21/12 newsletter fascinating as it highlights yet another concrete example of this sad scheme that the Chicken Little crowd might have a tough time brushing off.

pillsIn particular, Cott cites the 7/2/12 article by Christopher Knight in the LA Times that reports the Barnes Foundation museum’s claim of financial crisis was actually fabricated in order to facilitate the museum’s relocation efforts. Knight sources a blog post by former Barnes president and chief executive, Kimberly Camp, which reportedly confirms the finical crisis hype (final paragraph).

Hopefully, this will help put to rest any remaining debate on whether or not an arts organization can exaggerate a negative financial position as a means to an end.

It’s sad, but it happens.

But the real danger here is every time one group cries wolf, it makes everything much more difficult for the dozens of groups that aren’t exaggerating their respective financial position. The results can manifest in stakeholders and donors entrenching positions, sowing mistrust, and giving credence to fringe elements that are all too happy to launch some mindless jihad of a labor dispute to settle whatever old score is on their personal sh*t list.

Up until the turn of the century, there was a good system of self regulation in the field that prevented this sort of monkey business from getting out of hand and restricted it to a comparatively minor posturing tactic during negotiations. Sure, everyone knew it happened, but it was limited and anyone stepping outside of those boundaries would get smacked down in the form of career suicide.

But over the past decade, that system of self regulation has been slowly eroding and I prefer not to think about what might happen if it continues unchecked. Welcome to the age of new models.

4 Responses to Imaginary Fiscal Distress Syndrome

  1. Aaron Andersen August 22, 2012 at 12:26 pm #

    “But the real danger here is every time one group cries wolf, it makes everything much more difficult for the dozens of groups that aren’t exaggerating their respective financial position.”

    Yes, I completely agree. But I have to wonder, where were the auditors? And if the auditors were doing their jobs, where were the journalists who knew how to read audited financial reports? Maybe not working the arts beat? There are other checks and balances besides “self-regulation.”

    • Drew McManus August 22, 2012 at 5:07 pm #

      Absolutely, there are plenty of other checks and balances via traditional means; the history of self regulation is a much looser code of conduct among executives. Certainly nothing that even comes close to approaching being codified in writing but more of a general understanding of where the line is and how much you can dance on it without doing any career damage. These are rarely perfect scenarios but they can, and do, play crucial roles in maintaining overall stability in the field and the orchestra field is really beginning to feel the impact of the erosion.

      I always feel for traditional print media culture journalists covering these situations as the complexity and depth of information goes beyond their typical training. Add to that an office environment with fewer support services due to cutbacks and it leaves outlets with two unpalatable options: publish something incomplete or don’t publish anything.

  2. Lisa Hirsch August 23, 2012 at 12:09 am #

    Thanks for this – I should blog it, or maybe rub it in a certain person’s face.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Imaginary Fiscal Distress Syndrome or “How Pollyanna looks at Orchestra Management” | Mae Mai - January 12, 2013

    […] in other words, what Drew McManus calls the Imaginary Fiscal Distress Syndrome is simply a normal tactic used in business and seems to be the case with the Minnesota […]

Leave a Reply

Navigation